K018 $K_{l3}: K \to \pi e \nu \,\text{ and }\, K \to \pi \mu \nu; |V_{us}| f_+(0)$

Kaon semileptonic decays and source-level $V_{us}$ input
Status REVIEWED VERIFIED High Code: PARTIAL Priority Low

Why this constrains the RS scan

This is a tree-level charged-current process, not a neutral-meson \(\Delta F=2\) observable. In the current quark scan it is relevant mainly as the semileptonic source behind the fitted \(|V_{us}|\) target and the EW002 first-row unitarity test. Nonminimal warped models with modified \(W\)-quark couplings, vector-like fermion mixing, lepton nonuniversality, or right-handed charged currents could shift the extracted \(V_{us}\) or the \(K_{\mu3}/K_{e3}\) consistency test, but a minimal KK-gluon flavor analysis does not map this measurement into the existing operator basis.

What's changed since the original paper

The 2008 RS-flavor baseline CsakiFalkowskiWeiler:RSFlavor2008 centered on flavor-changing neutral constraints, so the post-2008 K018 story is precision charged-current consolidation. The sidecar entries FlaviaNet2010:K018:average\_fplus\_vus and FlaviaNet2010:K018:r\_mue record the 2010 FlaviaNet average \(|V_{us}|f_+(0)=0.2163(5)\) and \(K_{\mu3}/K_{e3}\) universality ratio \(r_{\mu e}=1.002(5)\). The 2025 PDG update keeps the same source-level convention while tightening the average to \(0.21656(35)\). FLAG 2024 supplies the auxiliary lattice normalization, \(f_+(0)=0.9698(17)\), and the derived \(|V_{us}|=0.22328(58)\), which feed the CKM-unitarity entry rather than replacing the measured K018 product.

Validity and model dependence

The measured \(|V_{us}|f_+(0)\) product is experimentally robust but depends on consistent radiative, isospin, and phase-space conventions. The derived \(|V_{us}|\) additionally depends on the lattice \(f_+(0)\) average. As an RS constraint, K018 is model-dependent: it is a charged-current CKM and lepton-universality diagnostic, not a standalone FCNC bound unless the model specifies nonstandard \(W\), scalar, tensor, or right-handed-current effects.

Code coverage in this repo

PARTIAL. The repo has a generic CKM target containing \(|V_{us}|\): quarkConstraints/scan.py:43 documents the PDG-derived CKM averages, quarkConstraints/scan.py:247 labels the reduced CKM observable as Vus, and tests/test\_quark\_fit.py:587 anchors the target against PDG 2024. The coverage grep found no \(K_{\ell3}\) decay-rate, \(|V_{us}|f_+(0)\), \(f_+(0)\), \(K_{e3}\), or \(K_{\mu3}\) implementation. The modern flavor surface is still limited to \(\varepsilon_K\), \(K\), \(B_d\), \(B_s\), and \(D0\) systems at quarkConstraints/modern/phenomenology.py:23.

Linked evidence (opens GitHub blob at flavor-catalog-website/2026q2):

Implementation difficulty

HIGH. A live K018 constraint would need a charged-current semileptonic likelihood or EFT wrapper, radiative/isospin convention bookkeeping, lattice \(f_+(0)\) provenance, and a decision about whether it is implemented as a direct \(V_{us}\) target, an EW002 sub-input, or a BSM charged-current operator constraint. The existing \(\Delta F=2\) SLL/SLR/VLL/VRR/LR machinery does not cover it.

Reason: A live K018 constraint requires a new charged-current semileptonic observable or EW002 sub-likelihood, radiative/isospin and phase-space conventions, lattice f_+(0) provenance, and BSM charged-current matching. Existing $\Delta F = 2$ operators do not cover it.

Key references

  • PDG2025:K018Kl3: PDG 2025 \(K_{\ell3}\) product average and mode values.
  • FLAG2024:K018KaonSemileptonic: lattice \(f_+(0)\) normalization and derived \(|V_{us}|\).
  • FlaviaNet:K018Kaon2010: post-2008 \(K_{\ell3}\) consolidation and \(r_{\mu e}\).
  • CsakiFalkowskiWeiler:RSFlavor2008: 2008 warped-flavor context.
Source SHAs
4 snapshot(s) tracked in flavor_catalog/processes/kaon/K018.yaml
Access dates
2026-05-16
Worklog
flavor_catalog/worklogs/K018/
LaTeX source
flavor_catalog/processes/kaon/K018.tex
Anchors generated
2026-05-18T02:01:25Z

PDG2025:K018:average_fplus_vus

https://pdg.lbl.gov/2025/reviews/rpp2025-rev-vud-vus.pdf
accessed 2026-05-16 sha e900e36b74e3... snapshot K018/pdg2025_vud_vus_kl3.txt AMBIGUOUS
value_summary |V_us| f_+(0) = 0.21656(35), average including correlation effects
AMBIGUOUS
Match 1 of 2 snapshot line 30
L27: K_L mu3           0.2165(6)
L28: K_S e3            0.2169(8)
L29: K_S mu3           0.2125(47)
L30: Average           0.21656(35)
L31: 
L32: Equation (67.11): f_+(0) |Vus| = 0.21656(35), labeled FLAVIANET.
L33: 
Match 2 of 2 snapshot line 32
L29: K_S mu3           0.2125(47)
L30: Average           0.21656(35)
L31: 
L32: Equation (67.11): f_+(0) |Vus| = 0.21656(35), labeled FLAVIANET.
L33: 
L34: The same passage states that the result leads to
L35: |Vus| = 0.22330(35)_exp (39)_LAT (8)_RC+IB (53)_TOT.
Snapshots live under flavor_catalog/references/<process_id>/. Source-line anchoring is automated; the status pill reflects match confidence, not editorial review.

PDG2025:K018:Kpm_e3

https://pdg.lbl.gov/2025/reviews/rpp2025-rev-vud-vus.pdf
accessed 2026-05-16 sha e900e36b74e3... snapshot K018/pdg2025_vud_vus_kl3.txt RESOLVED
value_uncertainty 0.2169(6)
RESOLVED
Match snapshot line 24
L21: Table 67.1: |Vus| f_+(0) from K_l3, based on Refs. [25,56]
L22: 
L23: Decay mode        |Vus| f_+(0)
L24: K+- e3            0.2169(6)
L25: K+- mu3           0.2168(10)
L26: K_L e3            0.2162(5)
L27: K_L mu3           0.2165(6)
Snapshots live under flavor_catalog/references/<process_id>/. Source-line anchoring is automated; the status pill reflects match confidence, not editorial review.

PDG2025:K018:Kpm_mu3

https://pdg.lbl.gov/2025/reviews/rpp2025-rev-vud-vus.pdf
accessed 2026-05-16 sha e900e36b74e3... snapshot K018/pdg2025_vud_vus_kl3.txt RESOLVED
value_uncertainty 0.2168(10)
RESOLVED
Match snapshot line 25
L22: 
L23: Decay mode        |Vus| f_+(0)
L24: K+- e3            0.2169(6)
L25: K+- mu3           0.2168(10)
L26: K_L e3            0.2162(5)
L27: K_L mu3           0.2165(6)
L28: K_S e3            0.2169(8)
Snapshots live under flavor_catalog/references/<process_id>/. Source-line anchoring is automated; the status pill reflects match confidence, not editorial review.

PDG2025:K018:KL_e3

https://pdg.lbl.gov/2025/reviews/rpp2025-rev-vud-vus.pdf
accessed 2026-05-16 sha e900e36b74e3... snapshot K018/pdg2025_vud_vus_kl3.txt RESOLVED
value_uncertainty 0.2162(5)
RESOLVED
Match snapshot line 26
L23: Decay mode        |Vus| f_+(0)
L24: K+- e3            0.2169(6)
L25: K+- mu3           0.2168(10)
L26: K_L e3            0.2162(5)
L27: K_L mu3           0.2165(6)
L28: K_S e3            0.2169(8)
L29: K_S mu3           0.2125(47)
Snapshots live under flavor_catalog/references/<process_id>/. Source-line anchoring is automated; the status pill reflects match confidence, not editorial review.

PDG2025:K018:KL_mu3

https://pdg.lbl.gov/2025/reviews/rpp2025-rev-vud-vus.pdf
accessed 2026-05-16 sha e900e36b74e3... snapshot K018/pdg2025_vud_vus_kl3.txt RESOLVED
value_uncertainty 0.2165(6)
RESOLVED
Match snapshot line 27
L24: K+- e3            0.2169(6)
L25: K+- mu3           0.2168(10)
L26: K_L e3            0.2162(5)
L27: K_L mu3           0.2165(6)
L28: K_S e3            0.2169(8)
L29: K_S mu3           0.2125(47)
L30: Average           0.21656(35)
Snapshots live under flavor_catalog/references/<process_id>/. Source-line anchoring is automated; the status pill reflects match confidence, not editorial review.

PDG2025:K018:KS_e3

https://pdg.lbl.gov/2025/reviews/rpp2025-rev-vud-vus.pdf
accessed 2026-05-16 sha e900e36b74e3... snapshot K018/pdg2025_vud_vus_kl3.txt RESOLVED
value_uncertainty 0.2169(8)
RESOLVED
Match snapshot line 28
L25: K+- mu3           0.2168(10)
L26: K_L e3            0.2162(5)
L27: K_L mu3           0.2165(6)
L28: K_S e3            0.2169(8)
L29: K_S mu3           0.2125(47)
L30: Average           0.21656(35)
L31: 
Snapshots live under flavor_catalog/references/<process_id>/. Source-line anchoring is automated; the status pill reflects match confidence, not editorial review.

PDG2025:K018:KS_mu3

https://pdg.lbl.gov/2025/reviews/rpp2025-rev-vud-vus.pdf
accessed 2026-05-16 sha e900e36b74e3... snapshot K018/pdg2025_vud_vus_kl3.txt RESOLVED
value_uncertainty 0.2125(47)
RESOLVED
Match snapshot line 29
L26: K_L e3            0.2162(5)
L27: K_L mu3           0.2165(6)
L28: K_S e3            0.2169(8)
L29: K_S mu3           0.2125(47)
L30: Average           0.21656(35)
L31: 
L32: Equation (67.11): f_+(0) |Vus| = 0.21656(35), labeled FLAVIANET.
Snapshots live under flavor_catalog/references/<process_id>/. Source-line anchoring is automated; the status pill reflects match confidence, not editorial review.

FlaviaNet2010:K018:average_fplus_vus

https://arxiv.org/abs/1005.2323
accessed 2026-05-16 sha c8855c1e4539... snapshot K018/flavianet2010_kl3.txt AMBIGUOUS
value_uncertainty 0.2163(5)
AMBIGUOUS
Match 1 of 3 snapshot line 24
L21: dispersive fits, long-distance radiative corrections, and SU(2)
L22: breaking corrections. The principal experimental result is:
L23: 
L24: |Vus| f_+(0) = 0.2163(5)
L25: 
L26: It reports chi2/ndf = 0.77/4, P = 94%.
L27: 
Match 2 of 3 snapshot line 36
L33: K_S -> pi e nu    0.2155(13)
L34: K+- -> pi e nu    0.2160(11)
L35: K+- -> pi mu nu   0.2158(14)
L36: Average           0.2163(5)
L37: 
L38: Section 4.3 compares Ke3 and Kmu3 values as a lepton-universality
L39: test and gives:
Match 3 of 3 snapshot line 43
L40: 
L41: r_mu e = 1.002(5)
L42: 
L43: Section 4.5 uses |Vus| f_+(0) = 0.2163(5) with f_+(0) = 0.959(5)
L44: and K_l2 information for a then-current CKM unitarity test; it finds:
L45: 
L46: Delta_CKM = -0.0001(6)
Snapshots live under flavor_catalog/references/<process_id>/. Source-line anchoring is automated; the status pill reflects match confidence, not editorial review.

FlaviaNet2010:K018:r_mue

https://arxiv.org/abs/1005.2323
accessed 2026-05-16 sha c8855c1e4539... snapshot K018/flavianet2010_kl3.txt RESOLVED
value_uncertainty 1.002(5)
RESOLVED
Match snapshot line 41
L38: Section 4.3 compares Ke3 and Kmu3 values as a lepton-universality
L39: test and gives:
L40: 
L41: r_mu e = 1.002(5)
L42: 
L43: Section 4.5 uses |Vus| f_+(0) = 0.2163(5) with f_+(0) = 0.959(5)
L44: and K_l2 information for a then-current CKM unitarity test; it finds:
Snapshots live under flavor_catalog/references/<process_id>/. Source-line anchoring is automated; the status pill reflects match confidence, not editorial review.

PDG2025:K018:Vus_from_Kl3

https://pdg.lbl.gov/2025/reviews/rpp2025-rev-vud-vus.pdf
accessed 2026-05-16 sha e900e36b74e3... snapshot K018/pdg2025_vud_vus_kl3.txt RESOLVED
value_uncertainty 0.22330(53)
RESOLVED
Match snapshot line 35
L32: Equation (67.11): f_+(0) |Vus| = 0.21656(35), labeled FLAVIANET.
L33: 
L34: The same passage states that the result leads to
L35: |Vus| = 0.22330(35)_exp (39)_LAT (8)_RC+IB (53)_TOT.
L36: 
L37: FLAG lattice inputs quoted by PDG in Eq. (67.12):
L38: f_+(0) = 0.9677(27), Nf = 2 + 1
Snapshots live under flavor_catalog/references/<process_id>/. Source-line anchoring is automated; the status pill reflects match confidence, not editorial review.

FLAG2024:K018:fplus_Nf211

https://arxiv.org/abs/2411.04268
accessed 2026-05-16 sha 7a1062d3a82b... snapshot K018/flag2024_kaon_semileptonic.txt RESOLVED
value_uncertainty 0.9698(17)
RESOLVED
Match snapshot line 25
L22: is based on FNAL/MILC 18 and ETM 16, while the Nf = 2 + 1 average is
L23: based on FNAL/MILC 12I and RBC/UKQCD 15A:
L24: 
L25: direct, Nf = 2 + 1 + 1: f_+(0) = 0.9698(17)
L26: direct, Nf = 2 + 1:     f_+(0) = 0.9677(27)
L27: 
L28: FLAG Section 5.3.3 converts these averages into CKM elements. For
Snapshots live under flavor_catalog/references/<process_id>/. Source-line anchoring is automated; the status pill reflects match confidence, not editorial review.

FLAG2024:K018:Vus_from_fplus_Nf211

https://arxiv.org/abs/2411.04268
accessed 2026-05-16 sha 7a1062d3a82b... snapshot K018/flag2024_kaon_semileptonic.txt RESOLVED
value_uncertainty 0.22328(58)
RESOLVED
Match snapshot line 31
L28: FLAG Section 5.3.3 converts these averages into CKM elements. For
L29: Nf = 2 + 1 + 1, Eq. (72) maps into:
L30: 
L31: |Vus| = 0.22328(58)
L32: 
L33: FLAG Section 5.4 tests first-row CKM unitarity. Combining f_+(0) for
L34: Nf = 2 + 1 + 1 with the PDG estimate of |Vud| gives:
Snapshots live under flavor_catalog/references/<process_id>/. Source-line anchoring is automated; the status pill reflects match confidence, not editorial review.