CR004 $pp \to B \bar{B} \to tW/bZ/bH + X$

Pair production of custodial charge -1/3 bottom partner B
Status REVIEWED VERIFIED High Code: NO Priority Medium

PDG / equivalent values

Observable Value Year Experiment / source Provenance
$m_B$ lower limit from pp $ \to $ B $\bar{B}$, B(B $ \to $ H b)=1 m_B > 1570 GeV
95% CL (lower_limit)
2025 CMS source ↑
$m_B$ lower limit from pp $ \to $ B $\bar{B}$, B(B $ \to $ Z b)=1 m_B > 1540 GeV
95% CL (lower_limit)
2025 CMS source ↑
$m_B$ lower limit from pp $ \to $ B $\bar{B}$, B(B $ \to $ W t)=1 m_B > 1560 GeV
95% CL (lower_limit)
2025 CMS source ↑

Why this constrains the RS scan

In custodial RS and composite-Higgs language, the \(B\) state is a physical fermion resonance, not the KK gluon itself. A direct \(B\bar B\) search therefore constrains \(m_B\) under a specified custodial multiplet and decay pattern; it becomes a constraint on \(M_{\mathrm{KK}}\) only after choosing the model relation between the light bottom partner and the gauge/fermion KK scale. Pair production is comparatively robust because it is QCD driven, but the mass exclusion still depends on the signal width, the allowed decays, and the branching fractions into \(tW\), \(bZ\), and \(bH\). For the RS scan in this repo, CR004 is a cross-check rather than the leading bound. The this repository quark-scan methodology note reports \(M_{\mathrm{KK}}^{\min}(p50,g_\ast=3)=47.26~\mathrm{TeV}\) from the low-energy flavor scan, with \(127.13~\mathrm{TeV}\) at \(95\%\) acceptance. That scale is far above the present direct \(B\)-partner reach near \(1.5~\mathrm{TeV}\). The collider entry is still useful for non-anarchic RS variants, custodial spectra where fermion partners sit well below the gauge KK scale, or benchmark points tuned to evade the low-energy flavor envelope.

What's changed since the original paper

The pre-LHC RS-motivated baseline is Contino--Servant arXiv:0801.1679, which emphasized same-sign dileptons from \(B,T_{5/3}\to Wt\) in custodial top-partner spectra. Post-2010 LHC work turned that benchmark strategy into broad branching-fraction searches: ATLAS arXiv:1808.02343 combined 13 TeV searches across the \(T\) and \(B\) decay simplex; CMS arXiv:2008.09835 made fully hadronic \(bH/bZ\) final states competitive with leptonic channels; CMS arXiv:2209.07327 used single-lepton, same-sign dilepton, and multilepton categories and drives the PDG \(B\to Wt\) corner; and ATLAS arXiv:2210.15413 plus arXiv:2212.05263 are full-Run-2 \(Z+\)third-generation and high-\(E_T^{\rm miss}\) cross-checks. The current CMS arXiv:2402.13808 result added a \(0\ell/2\ell\) combination with HEPData exclusion contours over the \(bH\), \(bZ\), and \(tW\) branching simplex. The CMS arXiv:2405.17605 review is used as Run-2 synthesis, not as a new measured limit.

Validity and model dependence

The quoted limits are valid as direct LHC mass-exclusion statements for prompt, narrow enough, pair-produced \(B\) quarks with the stated branching assumptions. They are not inclusive limits on every custodial-RS bottom partner. A broad resonance, nonstandard cascade decays, additional nearly degenerate partners, altered \(B\)-tag/Higgs/Z acceptances, or branching fractions spread across several modes can move the bound. A single production bound can reach higher masses, but it is controlled by electroweak mixing/coupling choices and is therefore not the canonical CR004 pair-production observable.

Code coverage in this repo

NO. The required code-coverage grep over quarkConstraints/, qcd/, flavorConstraints/, neutrinos/, yukawa/, warpConfig/, solvers/, scanParams/, and tests/ found no direct collider constraint, VLQ object, branching-simplex filter, or ATLAS/CMS/HEPData limit ingestion. The collider/VLQ query returned only tests/test\_alpha\_s.py:88 and tests/test\_alpha\_s.py:89, a \(\alpha_s\) CMS/RunDec example, not an LHC search. Nearby evidence is flavor-only: scanParams/scan.py:399 computes \(M_{\mathrm{KK}}\) for a scan row and scanParams/scan.py:523 applies the \(\mu\to e\gamma\) check, while quarkConstraints/scan.py:359 maps \(\Lambda_{\rm IR}\) to \(M_{\mathrm{KK}}\) and quarkConstraints/scan.py:377 evaluates \(\Delta F=2\) constraints.

Implementation difficulty

HIGH. A faithful implementation needs external LHC likelihoods or a reinterpretation chain such as CheckMATE, MadAnalysis5, or SModelS, plus signal generation for the custodial spectrum, widths, branching fractions, detector acceptances, and correlations across final states. A simple hard-coded mass veto would be easy but would be misleading for RS scans because \(m_B/M_{\mathrm{KK}}\), widths, and \(B\to tW,bZ,bH\) fractions are model dependent.

Reason: A faithful constraint needs LHC likelihoods or reinterpretation tooling, signal generation for RS custodial spectra, widths, branching fractions, detector acceptances, and correlated final-state combinations. A hard mass cut would be model-dependent and misleading.

Key references

PDG2025\_BPrimeListing; ContinoServant2008\_TopPartners; ATLAS2018\_VLQCombination; CMS2020\_BVLQFullyHadronic; CMS2023\_VLQLeptonic; ATLAS2023\_ZThirdGen; ATLAS2023\_METPartners; CMS2024\_BVLQDilepHad; HEPData2024\_BVLQContours; CMS2025\_VLQReview.
Source SHAs
12 snapshot(s) tracked in flavor_catalog/processes/collider_rs/CR004.yaml
Access dates
2026-05-17
Worklog
flavor_catalog/worklogs/CR004/
LaTeX source
flavor_catalog/processes/collider_rs/CR004.tex
Anchors generated
2026-05-17T21:55:00-04:00

PDG2025:CR004:B_bH_pair_mass_limit

https://pdg.lbl.gov/2025/listings/rpp2025-list-b-prime-quark.pdf
accessed 2026-05-17 sha bca9c8ebe557... snapshot CR004/pdg2025_bprime_listing.txt UNRESOLVED
display m_B > 1570 GeV
UNRESOLVED

Automated anchoring could not pinpoint this value inside the snapshot. Manual verification is needed: open the live source and confirm against the context surrounding the value claim.

Open source manually
Snapshots live under flavor_catalog/references/<process_id>/. Source-line anchoring is automated; the status pill reflects match confidence, not editorial review.

PDG2025:CR004:B_bZ_pair_mass_limit

https://pdg.lbl.gov/2025/listings/rpp2025-list-b-prime-quark.pdf
accessed 2026-05-17 sha bca9c8ebe557... snapshot CR004/pdg2025_bprime_listing.txt RESOLVED
display m_B > 1540 GeV
RESOLVED
Match snapshot line 11
L8: b′ (−1/3)-quark/hadron mass limits in p p and p p collisions
L9: VALUE (GeV)               CL%           DOCUMENT ID               TECN     COMMENT
L10: >1530                     95        1 AAD         24BP ATLS                B(b ′ → W u) = 1
L11: >1540                     95        2 HAYRAPETY...24AQ CMS                 B(b ′ → Z b) = 1
L12: >1570                     95        2 HAYRAPETY...24AQ CMS                 B(b ′ → H b) = 1
L13: >1560                     95        3 TUMASYAN 23V CMS                     B(b ′ → W t) = 1
L14: >1570                     95        4 SIRUNYAN    20BI CMS                 B(b ′ → H b) = 1
Snapshots live under flavor_catalog/references/<process_id>/. Source-line anchoring is automated; the status pill reflects match confidence, not editorial review.

PDG2025:CR004:B_tW_pair_mass_limit

https://pdg.lbl.gov/2025/listings/rpp2025-list-b-prime-quark.pdf
accessed 2026-05-17 sha bca9c8ebe557... snapshot CR004/pdg2025_bprime_listing.txt UNRESOLVED
display m_B > 1560 GeV
UNRESOLVED

Automated anchoring could not pinpoint this value inside the snapshot. Manual verification is needed: open the live source and confirm against the context surrounding the value claim.

Open source manually
Snapshots live under flavor_catalog/references/<process_id>/. Source-line anchoring is automated; the status pill reflects match confidence, not editorial review.